Online Table Games

Best American NHL Players of All Time

The American list is crowded with elite talent, but Patrick Kane and Mike Modano sit at the center of most modern rankings. ESPN and other outlets often place Kane at number one among American-born players: three Cups, a Hart Trophy, a Conn Smythe, an Art Ross, and nearly 1,400 points as one of the most skilled wingers of his generation. Mike Modano long held the title of top American skater, finishing with 561 goals, 1,374 points, a Stanley Cup in Dallas, and huge impact in growing the game in non-traditional markets. Behind them are multiple Hall of Famers and Cup winners: Brett Hull, Chris Chelios, Brian Leetch, Jeremy Roenick, Pat LaFontaine, and Joe Mullen.

January 25, 2026

The Top 20 American NHL Players

1. Patrick Kane: The Modern Standard

Patrick Kane has established himself as the greatest American NHL player.

Career Highlights:

1,370+ career points (500 goals, 870 assists)
Three Stanley Cups (2010, 2013, 2015)
Hart Trophy (2016)
Conn Smythe Trophy (2013)
Art Ross Trophy (2016)

Skill Level: Kane's stickhandling, vision, and creativity make him one of the most skilled players regardless of nationality. His ability to create offense from nothing separated him from peers.

Championship Success: Core member of Chicago's dynasty, winning Conn Smythe in 2013 with elite playoff performance.

If you know which NHL stars are Swedish, Finnish, Russian, or Czech, you'll love Gridzy Hockey — birthplace categories show up constantly in the daily grid.

2. Mike Modano: The Dallas Icon

Mike Modano was the face of American hockey for two decades.

Career Stats:

1,374 career points (561 goals, 813 assists)
Stanley Cup champion (1999)
Eight All-Star selections
First American to 500 goals

Impact Beyond Stats: Modano's success in Dallas helped grow hockey in non-traditional markets, proving Americans could be franchise players.

Legacy: Held American scoring records until Kane's generation, Hall of Fame inductee first ballot.

3. Brett Hull: "The Golden Brett"

Though he represented Canada and USA internationally, Hull was American-born.

Production:

1,391 career points (741 goals, 650 assists)
Two Stanley Cups
Hart Trophy (1991)
50-goal seasons: 5

Goal-Scoring: One of the greatest pure goal scorers ever, with elite one-timer and positioning.

4. Chris Chelios: Longevity and Defense

The standard for American defensemen.

Career Overview:

948 career points (185 goals, 763 assists)
Three Norris Trophies (1989, 1993, 1996)
Three Stanley Cups
1,651 games played (26 seasons)

Defensive Excellence: Elite shutdown defender who could also contribute offensively, played until age 48.

Think you can name elite players born outside North America? Try Gridzy and see how fast you can solve the "born outside NA" squares.

5. Brian Leetch: Offensive Blue-Line Brilliance

New York Rangers legend and elite offensive defenseman.

Accomplishments:

1,028 career points (247 goals, 781 assists)
Two Norris Trophies (1992, 1997)
Conn Smythe Trophy (1994)
Stanley Cup champion (1994)

Impact: One of the best American-born offensive defensemen ever, defined Rangers' defense for over a decade.

6. Joe Mullen: First American 500-Goal Scorer

Hall of Fame winger who blazed trails.

Career Stats:

1,063 career points (502 goals, 561 assists)
Three Stanley Cups
Lady Byng Trophy (1987, 1989)
First American with 500 goals

7. Jeremy Roenick: Skill and Personality

Elite two-way center with scoring touch.

Production:

1,216 career points (513 goals, 703 assists)
Multiple 100-point seasons
Nine All-Star selections
Elite two-way play

8. Pat LaFontaine: Peak Excellence

Career cut short by concussions, but peak was elite.

Stats:

1,013 career points (468 goals, 545 assists)
Multiple 100-point seasons
1.17 points per game
Hall of Fame inductee

9. Phil Kessel: Consistent Scorer

Elite goal-scorer across 17 seasons.

Career:

1,000+ career points (413 goals, 587+ assists)
Two Stanley Cups (2016, 2017)
Multiple 30+ goal seasons
Ironman streak (989 consecutive games)

10. Zach Parise: Two-Way Excellence

Complete forward with scoring and defensive ability.

Production:

900+ career points (421 goals, 480+ assists)
Multiple 40-goal seasons
Elite two-way forward
Olympic hero

This is exactly the kind of knowledge that wins grid games. Play Gridzy Hockey and turn your country-by-country NHL knowledge into a daily challenge.

11-20: The Next Tier

11. Keith Tkachuk: 1,065 points, physical power forward 12. Adam Fox: Norris Trophy (2021), elite young defenseman 13. Auston Matthews: 302+ goals, Rocket Richard winner, still building legacy 14. Jack Eichel: 500+ points, elite center, Stanley Cup champion (2023) 15. Matthew Tkachuk: 600+ points, Stanley Cup champion (2024), elite two-way forward 16. Jonathan Quick: 403 wins, two Stanley Cups, elite goaltender 17. Ryan Miller: 391 wins, Vezina Trophy (2010), Olympic hero 18. Ryan Suter: 650+ points, elite two-way defenseman, 1,400+ games 19. Dustin Brown: Stanley Cup champion (2012, 2014), LA Kings captain 20. James van Riemsdyk: 600+ points, consistent 25-30 goal scorer

Kane vs. Modano: The Debate

Case for Patrick Kane:

Three Stanley Cups vs. one
Hart Trophy, Conn Smythe, Art Ross
More career points (1,370 vs. 1,374 essentially tied)
Elite skill level
Championship pedigree

Case for Mike Modano:

Pioneer for American hockey
First American to 500 goals
Grew game in Dallas
Two-way excellence
Historical significance

Consensus: Most modern rankings place Kane first due to three Cups and elite skill, but Modano's pioneering impact keeps debate alive.

American Defensemen: Chelios and Leetch

Chris Chelios: The Ironman

Three Norris Trophies and unmatched longevity:

Dominance:

1,651 games across 26 seasons
Three Stanley Cups
Elite two-way play
Played until age 48

Brian Leetch: Offensive Brilliance

Rangers legend and Conn Smythe winner:

Excellence:

1,028 career points
Two Norris Trophies
1994 Conn Smythe
Elite power-play quarterback

Both represent different eras and styles of American defensive excellence.

Modern American Stars

Auston Matthews: The Next Generation

Building case for top 10 all-time American:

Production:

302+ goals in 482 games
Multiple Rocket Richard Trophies
60+ goal season
Elite shooting percentage

Projection: Could crack top 5 all-time Americans with sustained excellence and Cup win.

Adam Fox: Elite Young Defenseman

Norris Trophy winner building elite career:

Accomplishments:

Norris Trophy (2021)
Elite two-way play
Rangers' top defenseman
Potential for multiple Norris wins

Jack Eichel and Matthew Tkachuk

Both building strong cases:

Eichel:

Stanley Cup champion (2023)
Elite playmaking center
500+ points

Tkachuk:

Stanley Cup champion (2024)
600+ points
Elite two-way forward
Physical edge

The 1980 "Miracle on Ice" Legacy

Olympic Gold vs. NHL Careers

The 1980 Olympic team produced some NHL players but limited superstars:

Mike Ramsey:

1,070 games as defenseman
Longest NHL career from team
Buffalo Sabres mainstay

Neal Broten:

Stanley Cup champion (1995)
923 career points
Elite playmaker

Olympic Impact: More cultural significance than NHL production, but sparked American hockey boom that produced Kane, Modano, and modern stars.

American Goaltending

Jonathan Quick: Championship Goalie

Two Stanley Cups define his legacy:

Stats:

403 career wins
Two Conn Smythe Trophies
Elite playoff performer
LA Kings dynasty

Ryan Miller: Elite Peak

Vezina Trophy and Olympic hero:

Career:

391 career wins
Vezina Trophy (2010)
Olympic silver medal MVP
Elite save percentage

American Talent Pipeline Explosion

1990s Onward: The Boom

American hockey development exploded:

Youth Programs: USA Hockey development programs produced elite talent.

College Hockey: NCAA became premier development route for Americans.

Modern Depth: USA now produces top-tier talent at every position annually.

Result: From sparse representation in 1970s to one of NHL's deepest talent pools.

American Production Leaders

Goals:

Brett Hull: 741
Mike Modano: 561
Jeremy Roenick: 513
Patrick Kane: 500
Keith Tkachuk: 538

Points:

Brett Hull: 1,391
Mike Modano: 1,374
Patrick Kane: 1,370
Jeremy Roenick: 1,216
Chris Chelios: 948 (defenseman)

Wins (Goalies):

Jonathan Quick: 403
Ryan Miller: 391
John Vanbiesbrouck: 374

Pure Production vs. All-Around Value

Scoring Leaders:

Kane, Modano, Hull focused on offensive dominance
Multiple 80+ point seasons
Elite playmaking and finishing

Two-Way Excellence:

Chelios, Leetch provided defensive value
Shutdown ability plus offense
Championship impact beyond points

Both approaches produced Hall of Fame careers and American hockey legends.

Play Gridzy Hockey Free Every Day

Gridzy Hockey is Shurzy's daily NHL grid game where you pretend you're "just messing around" and then suddenly you're 15 minutes deep arguing with yourself about whether some 2009 fourth-liner qualifies as a 40-goal guy.

You get nine guesses to fill a 3×3 grid, you can't reuse players, and every pick is either a genius flex or instant regret, so yeah, it's basically hockey trivia with stakes.

New grid drops every day at 6:00am ET, which is perfect because nothing says "healthy morning routine" like panicking over who won the Lady Byng in 1998. If you think you know puck, prove it.

Go play Gridzy right now!

‍

Share this post: