Best Sports Games Like FIFA / NHL / NBA 2K (Alternatives)

Arcade Soccer Alternatives

eFootball (Konami)

eFootball (formerly PES) is the main on-pitch rival to FIFA/EA Sports FC, focusing on more deliberate, simulation-leaning ball physics and build-up play. While its launch was rough, updates have improved responsiveness and modes, and it's now a legit free-to-play option if you want a different feel from EA's pace-heavy style.

The gameplay is slower and more methodical. Passing requires actual thought, first touches matter more, and the ball physics feel weightier. It won't appeal to everyone, but if FIFA feels too arcade-fast, eFootball delivers something closer to real soccer rhythm.

UFL

UFL is a newer free-to-play soccer title aiming to compete with FIFA/FC by focusing on fair matchmaking and skill-based online play. It features licensed clubs, modern graphics and a live-service structure, offering another alternative if you're tired of the Ultimate Team grind.

The big pitch is "fair play" with less pay-to-win mechanics than Ultimate Team. Early reception has been mixed, but it's free, looks decent, and offers a third option in the soccer sim market. Worth trying if you're curious about what a new competitor can bring.

Hockey Alternatives to EA's NHL

NHL 2K (Mobile & Legacy Consoles)

The NHL 2K series isn't current on PC/console, but the mobile version and older console entries (like NHL 2K10/2K11) still get love for their skating feel and franchise modes. If you can live with dated rosters, they offer a different handling model and presentation than EA's NHL, especially for offline franchise grinders.

NHL 2K7 is still considered by some as the best hockey sim ever made. The AI was smarter, the physics felt more realistic, and franchise mode had depth. The mobile version keeps that legacy alive with updated rosters from the community, though obviously with mobile-level graphics.

Want a hockey game you can play in under two minutes? Try Gridzy Hockey, a daily NHL grid game where every pick counts.

Franchise Hockey Manager / Eastside Hockey Manager (PC)

These are management-first hockey sims that ditch real-time gameplay for deep tactical and front-office control. You handle drafts, trades, contracts and tactics over decades, making them great alternatives if what you enjoy in NHL is roster building and franchise mode rather than stick-handling.

If you spend more time in NHL's franchise mode than actually playing games, these are pure upgrades. The depth is comparable to Football Manager but for hockey. You're scouting prospects, managing cap space, setting tactical systems, and watching your rebuild unfold over 20 seasons. 

Read more: All 32 NHL Teams Ranked for the 2025/2026 Season

Basketball Alternatives to NBA 2K

NBA Live 19 (Legacy EA)

Even though the NBA Live series is dormant, Live 19 still shows up in "best alternatives" lists because it has a more accessible, less animation-locked feel than modern 2K. It's a solid option if you want a decent-looking basketball game without diving into 2K's heavy VC and MyCareer ecosystems.

The gameplay feels faster and more responsive than 2K, though less realistic. There's no microtransaction grind, no forced story mode, and franchise mode is straightforward. It's dated now, but still playable if you can find it cheap and just want basketball without the baggage.

NBA 2K Playgrounds 2

Playgrounds 2 is an over-the-top 2-on-2 arcade game with exaggerated dunks and power-ups rather than sim basketball. It fills the same niche as old NBA Jam/NBA Street titles and works well as a "palette cleanser" if traditional 5-on-5 sims feel too serious.

The arcade action is pure fun. Big heads, massive dunks, and goofy power-ups make it perfect for casual sessions with friends. It won't scratch the sim itch, but if you miss NBA Jam's energy, Playgrounds 2 is the closest modern equivalent.

Multi-Sport & Niche Alternatives

Rocket League (Arcade Football)

Rocket League turns car-soccer into a high-skill esport, with precise physics, ranked play and short, intense matches. It's not a traditional football sim, but if what you love in FIFA is competitive, mechanical mastery, Rocket League scratches that itch in a totally different package.

The skill ceiling is ridiculously high. You're learning aerials, flip resets, air dribbles, and team rotations across hundreds of hours. Matches last five minutes, the competitive scene is massive, and the cross-platform play means you'll always find games. It's soccer meets physics puzzle.

Super Mega Baseball 4

Super Mega Baseball blends cartoony visuals with surprisingly deep pitching, batting and fielding systems. It's an excellent alternative if you like the feel of sports games like MLB The Show but want a more approachable, less heavily licensed experience.

The Ego difficulty system scales perfectly from casual to hardcore. Lower settings feel arcade-fun, higher settings require actual baseball knowledge and timing. Franchise mode is deep, the customization is extensive, and the gameplay holds up against The Show despite the cartoon aesthetic.

If you like quick browser games with real sports knowledge baked in, Gridzy is your new morning ritual: a fresh NHL grid drops daily at 6:00am ET.

eSports Boxing Club / Undisputed

Undisputed aims to be the most realistic boxing sim, with detailed footwork, stamina and punch mechanics. For fans of FIFA/NHL/NBA 2K who mainly want competitive 1v1 skill tests with strong animations and physics, it's a solid combat-sports pivot.

The boxing is methodical. Stamina management matters, punch selection requires strategy, and the career mode has depth. It's niche compared to the big sports games, but if you want a competitive sports experience that's all about reading your opponent and executing strategy, Undisputed delivers.

Football Manager 26

If your favourite part of FIFA is Career/Manager Mode, Football Manager 26 turns that slice into an entire game, with unmatched depth in tactics, scouting and club building. There's no direct-control gameplay, but as a management-only alternative it's the gold standard for long-term soccer immersion.

This is what FIFA's Career Mode wishes it could be. The tactical depth alone could fill a manual. You're handling press conferences, managing player personalities, navigating board expectations, and building a club identity over decades. If you love the manager role, FM26 is the only real option.

How to Pick the Right Alternative

Choose eFootball or UFL if you want on-pitch soccer that feels different from EA's engine.

Choose older NHL 2K or FHM/EHM if you love hockey but are burnt out on EA's yearly NHL loop.

Choose NBA Live or Playgrounds 2 if you're over 2K's grind and want a lighter or different feel.

Fold in Rocket League, Super Mega Baseball, Undisputed and Football Manager if you mainly crave strong physics, skill expression or deep team-building rather than brand names.

Play Gridzy Hockey Free Every Day

Gridzy Hockey is Shurzy's daily NHL grid game where you pretend you're "just messing around" and then suddenly you're 15 minutes deep arguing with yourself about whether some 2009 fourth-liner qualifies as a 40-goal guy.

You get nine guesses to fill a 3×3 grid, you can't reuse players, and every pick is either a genius flex or instant regret. So yeah, it's basically hockey trivia with stakes.

New grid drops every day at 6:00am ET, which is perfect because nothing says "healthy morning routine" like panicking over who won the Lady Byng in 1998. If you think you know puck, prove it.

Go play Gridzy right now!

‍