Online Table Games

Most Underrated 1,000-Point Players in NHL History

The 1,000-point club is loaded with Hall of Fame icons, but there's a quieter subset: players who passed 1,000 without ever becoming household names outside their markets. These underrated members often played on small-market teams, during low-scoring eras, or in the shadows of bigger stars. Names that often show up on underrated lists include Pierre Turgeon, Jeremy Roenick, Patrik Elias, Rod Brind'Amour, Vincent Damphousse, Bernie Nicholls, and others who sit around the 1,000-1,300 point range without iconic branding. The key is framing them relative to flashier peers with similar totals who get more attention.

January 25, 2026

Defining "Underrated" in the 1,000-Point Context

Not every 1,000-point player deserves equal recognition, but some have been unfairly overlooked:

Criteria for "Underrated":

Few major awards (Hart, Art Ross, Ted Lindsay)
Limited Hart Trophy voting presence
Late Hall of Fame induction or still waiting
Small-market teams or second-fiddle roles
Dead Puck Era production (lower raw totals)

What This List Is NOT: Not simply listing every 1,000-point player, but highlighting those underrepresented in awards, media coverage, or popular memory despite elite production.

These milestone lists aren't just trivia, they're cheat codes. Try Gridzy Hockey and use your 40-goal and 100-point knowledge to solve today's grid.

Pierre Turgeon: 1,327 Points

Career Overview:

515 goals, 812 assists
19 NHL seasons
Six different teams
No Hart Trophy, no major playoff spotlight

Why He's Underrated: Turgeon bounced through multiple markets (Buffalo, Montreal, St. Louis, Dallas, Colorado, Toronto), never establishing himself as a franchise icon despite elite production. His 1,327 points rank 38th all-time, yet he waited years for Hall of Fame induction (2023).

Peak Performance:

132 points (1992-93) with Islanders
Multiple 100+ point seasons
Elite playmaker and two-way center

Recognition Gap: Players with similar point totals (Mark Messier, Ron Francis) received far more accolades and media attention. Turgeon's quiet excellence went largely unnoticed.

Patrik Elias: 1,025 Points

Career Overview:

408 goals, 617 assists
20 NHL seasons (all with New Jersey)
Two Stanley Cups
New Jersey Devils franchise scoring leader

Why He's Underrated: Elias quietly amassed strong totals on a defense-first team built around Martin Brodeur and the neutral-zone trap. He never won major individual awards despite being Devils' best forward for over a decade.

Peak Performance:

96 points (2000-01)
Consistent 70-80 point producer
Elite two-way forward

Recognition Gap: Playing in New Jersey's defensive system limited offensive opportunities. Elias sacrificed individual stats for team success, getting overshadowed by flashier scorers on offensive teams.

If you love stats and milestones, Gridzy is built for you: a daily NHL grid where players must match stat thresholds, awards, and team history.

Rod Brind'Amour: 1,184 Points

Career Overview:

452 goals, 732 assists
21 NHL seasons
Stanley Cup champion (2006)
Two Selke Trophies

Why He's Underrated: Brind'Amour's reputation was more as a shutdown center than as a 1,000-point producer. His defensive excellence overshadowed his offensive contributions.

Peak Performance:

97 points (1992-93)
Multiple 70+ point seasons
Elite two-way play

Recognition Gap: Heavy usage in penalty-killing and shutdown roles limited gaudy offensive totals. Analytics show he was elite in all three zones, but his 1,000+ points often go unmentioned in his legacy discussions.

Vincent Damphousse: 1,205 Points

Career Overview:

432 goals, 773 assists
18 NHL seasons
Multiple teams (Toronto, Edmonton, Montreal, San Jose)
Stanley Cup champion (1993)

Why He's Underrated: Damphousse never had a signature 100-point season or won major individual awards. His consistent 70-80 point production over 18 years went largely unnoticed.

Peak Performance:

97 points (1991-92)
Six consecutive 70+ point seasons
Elite playmaker

Recognition Gap: Playing in markets like Montreal and San Jose during down years limited his exposure. He was always solid, never spectacular, making him easy to overlook.

Bernie Nicholls: 1,209 Points

Career Overview:

475 goals, 734 assists
18 NHL seasons
One massive outlier season

Why He's Underrated: Nicholls is remembered primarily for his 150-point season (1988-89) playing alongside Wayne Gretzky. His sustained excellence across 18 years gets overshadowed by that one peak.

Peak Performance:

150 points (1988-89)
Multiple 70+ point seasons
475 career goals

Recognition Gap: One-season wonder perception hurts his legacy. In reality, Nicholls was a consistent 30-goal, 70-point player for over a decade, accumulating 1,200+ points through longevity and steady production.

Ready to prove you know your 500-goal and 1,000-point guys? Gridzy Hockey turns those milestones into a daily puzzle, and you only get 9 guesses.

Jeremy Roenick: 1,216 Points

Career Overview:

513 goals, 703 assists
20 NHL seasons
Multiple teams (Chicago, Phoenix, Philadelphia, Los Angeles, San Jose)

Why He's Underrated: Roenick had personality and was known for his brash style, but his elite production often gets overlooked. He played in smaller markets for much of his career.

Peak Performance:

107 points (1992-93)
Multiple 100+ point seasons
Elite two-way center

Recognition Gap: Never won a Stanley Cup or major individual award. His outspoken personality sometimes overshadowed his on-ice excellence.

Dave Andreychuk: 1,338 Points

Career Overview:

640 goals, 698 assists
23 NHL seasons
Stanley Cup champion (2004)
Most power-play goals all-time (274)

Why He's Underrated: Andreychuk is the all-time power-play goal leader and seventh in career goals, yet rarely mentioned among elite scorers. His lack of individual awards and late-career Cup win limited his recognition.

Peak Performance:

99 points (1992-93)
Consistent 40-goal scorer
Net-front specialist

Recognition Gap: Power-play specialist reputation made him seem one-dimensional. In reality, he was an elite goal-scorer for two decades.

Era and Role Context

Dead Puck Era Impact: Many underrated 1,000-point players did their best work during the Dead Puck Era (mid-1990s to early 2000s), where 70-80 points was elite production.

Era-Adjusted Value:

Turgeon's 132 points (1992-93) came as scoring declined
Elias' 96 points in trap system comparable to 110+ in 1980s
Brind'Amour's two-way play suppressed raw totals

Shutdown Roles: Players like Brind'Amour heavy usage in penalty-killing and defensive matchups limited offensive opportunities but boosted overall team value.

Why They Didn't Get the Hype

Media Exposure: Small-market teams (Buffalo, Carolina, San Jose) received less coverage than Original Six or major Canadian markets.

Team Context: Many played second fiddle to bigger stars:

Turgeon behind Dale Hawerchuk in Buffalo
Elias behind Brodeur's shadow in New Jersey
Nicholls playing alongside Gretzky

Playoff Success: Lack of deep playoff runs or signature Conn Smythe moments limited their legacy-building opportunities.

Award Voting: Few Hart Trophy top-3 finishes meant less recognition from media and peers.

Analytics and Modern Evaluation

Rate Stats: Many underrated players had elite points-per-game rates:

Turgeon: 1.00 PPG
Brind'Amour: 0.74 PPG (plus elite defense)
Damphousse: 0.81 PPG

Era Adjustments: Using adjusted stats shows several underrated players rank among top 50-75 all-time when accounting for scoring environment.

WAR-Type Metrics: Modern analytics reveal players like Brind'Amour provided massive value through two-way play that raw point totals don't capture.

Hall of Fame Debates

Already Inducted:

Pierre Turgeon (2023, after long wait)
Rod Brind'Amour (2022)
Dave Andreychuk (2017)

Still Waiting:

Patrik Elias (eligible but not yet inducted)
Vincent Damphousse (eligible, Hall of Very Good)
Jeremy Roenick (multiple years of eligibility)

Shifting Standards: Hall of Fame bar has shifted over time. Some players inducted in 1980s-90s had fewer points than current players waiting.

Legacy: Quiet Excellence

The most underrated 1,000-point players share common traits:

Longevity and consistency over flash
Small-market or defensive-team contexts
Elite production without individual hardware
Overshadowed by contemporary superstars

These players deserve more recognition for sustained excellence across 15-20 NHL seasons, accumulating point totals that place them among hockey's all-time greats.

Play Gridzy Hockey Free Every Day

Gridzy Hockey is Shurzy's daily NHL grid game where you pretend you're "just messing around" and then suddenly you're 15 minutes deep arguing with yourself about whether some 2009 fourth-liner qualifies as a 40-goal guy.

You get nine guesses to fill a 3×3 grid, you can't reuse players, and every pick is either a genius flex or instant regret, so yeah, it's basically hockey trivia with stakes.

New grid drops every day at 6:00am ET, which is perfect because nothing says "healthy morning routine" like panicking over who won the Lady Byng in 1998. If you think you know puck, prove it.

Go play Gridzy right now!

‍

Share this post: