Sports Betting

NHL Surprise Teams Prediction 2026

Every season has teams that blow past expectations and teams that completely fall apart. Betting the surprises before the market notices is one of the cleanest edges in hockey. Preseason projections are built on last year's data, offseason transactions, and roster assumptions that don't always hold. When a young team clicks faster than expected, or an aging contender declines harder than projected, the odds don't adjust immediately. That gap is where the value lives.

March 18, 2026

Which Teams Are the Most Likely Positive Surprises?

These teams have the ingredients to dramatically outperform their preseason expectations.

Utah Mammoth: Power rankings have consistently framed Utah as a possible fast-tracker because of young scoring talent like Dylan Guenther and Logan Cooley. If goaltending holds and their young core develops on schedule, they can outpace the modest expectations that most preseason projections assigned them. Their surprise upside is the most realistic on this list given the pieces in place.
Anaheim Ducks: Leo Carlsson put up 26 points in 16 early games in one stretch, and that kind of production from a young centerpiece changes the entire narrative around a team. Anaheim is in a position to dramatically overshoot preseason win totals if their young talent continues to develop at an accelerated pace. Their points total and playoff make prices both deserve a second look.
Montreal Canadiens: A deep prospect pool plus emerging stars like Ivan Demidov and Zack Bolduc create a real "finally arrive" narrative that some bold-prediction lists have already flagged. Montreal's young core arriving simultaneously is the scenario that turns them from a bubble team into a genuine story.
Buffalo Sabres: Same profile as Montreal — young core, real offensive talent, a team that has been "about to break through" for two seasons now. If their defensive structure holds up and goaltending stays consistent, a significant positive surprise is genuinely on the table.

Which Teams Are the Most Likely Negative Surprises?

These are the teams most at risk of falling short of where the market currently has them.

Washington Capitals: A bold-predictions article specifically flagged Washington as a candidate to go from high seed to missing the playoffs entirely. The underlying numbers back up the concern — aging core, declining five-on-five dominance, and a roster that's been running on Ovechkin's individual brilliance for longer than sustainable. Their current odds to make the playoffs may still be shorter than their actual probability warrants.
Toronto Maple Leafs: ESPN flagged Toronto specifically as a team whose playoff odds have dropped substantially from preseason. Their star-heavy, depth-thin construction is exactly the profile that produces negative surprises when injuries or cold streaks hit at the wrong time.
Teams with suspect goaltending on short make prices: Any mid-tier team priced at -150 or shorter to make the playoffs that relies heavily on one goalie staying healthy is a genuine negative surprise candidate. Goaltending-dependent teams have the highest variance in the entire league, and that variance shows up most brutally in tight playoff races.

Before placing your next wager, take a look at the Live Odds on Shurzy. Compare current lines, futures markets, and betting trends across the NHL, NBA, MLB, UFC and more.

Which Mid-Tier Teams Could Swing Either Way?

Not every surprise is a blowout in one direction. Some teams are genuinely coin-flip situations where the outcome depends almost entirely on one or two variables breaking right or wrong.

Ottawa Senators: Ottawa is one of the most genuinely unpredictable teams in the East. Their young core has real offensive talent, and their power play is dangerous. But their penalty kill has been a liability all season, and their defensive structure leaks enough that a cold goaltending stretch can turn a winning month into a losing one almost overnight.
Winnipeg Jets: Winnipeg's entire season hinges on Connor Hellebuyck. When he's elite, they're a top-five team in the West and a genuine playoff threat. When he's human, they're a middle-of-the-pack team with a decent power play and not much else. The Jets are the most goalie-dependent team in the league, which means their actual outcome range is wider than their current odds reflect. Back them when Hellebuyck is sharp, fade them when he's not.
Detroit Red Wings: Detroit is right on the edge of the conversation in the East. Their young core is developing faster than most projected, and their defensive structure has improved meaningfully from previous seasons. The difference between a positive surprise and a near-miss for Detroit comes down to whether their scoring depth holds up over a full 82 games.
New Jersey Devils: The Devils have the offensive firepower to be a top-three team in the Metro on their best nights. Their problem is consistency. Defensive lapses and streaky goaltending keep pulling them back from the kind of sustained run that would push them into genuine contender territory.

How to Bet Surprise Teams Before the Market Moves

The whole point of identifying surprise teams is acting before the books adjust. Here's how to do that.

Season points total bets: Utah and Anaheim's points totals may still reflect preseason pessimism rather than current trajectory. If their over is still available at a reasonable price, that's the most direct way to bet a positive surprise.
Playoff make bets at plus money: Montreal and Buffalo to make the playoffs at plus money is the clearest expression of the positive surprise thesis. Real probability, meaningful payout, and teams the market hasn't fully bought into yet.
Fade aging contenders on moneyline: Washington's moneyline prices in divisional games against younger, faster opponents deserve a discount that the market sometimes doesn't apply. Fading them as favorites in specific matchups is a lower-risk way to express the negative surprise thesis without committing to a full-season miss bet.
Coach of the year markets: Positive surprise teams almost always produce a coach of the year candidate. If Utah or Anaheim goes on a significant run, their coaches become relevant in that market at prices that weren't interesting at the start of the year.

Looking for deeper analysis and original research? Visit the Shurzy Content Lab, where our team breaks down stats, trends, and betting insights across the biggest sports leagues.

‍

Share this post: