Sports Betting

NHL Teams Most Likely to Miss the Playoffs 2026

Some teams look safe until they aren't. That's where the money is. Playoff miss bets are one of the most underused angles in hockey betting. Bettors spend most of their time identifying who makes the playoffs, not who falls short. But the teams priced at short "yes" odds with fragile underlying numbers are exactly where fading the market pays off. Here's which teams are most likely to miss the 2026 playoffs and how to bet it.

March 18, 2026

Which Contenders Have Seen Their Playoff Odds Drop the Most?

Some teams that opened the season as near-locks have quietly become genuine bubble concerns.

Utah Mammoth and Toronto Maple Leafs are the two clearest examples of teams whose playoff odds have dropped substantially from their preseason pricing. Both opened with strong implied probability of making the field. Both have seen that number erode as the season progressed. ESPN specifically flagged these two as examples of how fragile some preseason locks can be.

The broader lesson here is that playoff odds markets have strong interdependence. When Utah's make probability drops, Winnipeg's rises. When Toronto struggles, Boston and Detroit benefit. These aren't isolated movements — they're connected, and tracking the relationships between bubble teams gives you a clearer picture of where the market is mispriced.

Which Eastern Conference Teams Are Most Likely to Miss?

The East bubble is crowded, and the books have already identified which teams are more likely to miss than make it.

Teams currently sitting at plus money to make the playoffs in the East — meaning the market implies they're more likely to miss than qualify — include Buffalo, Columbus, the Islanders, and a handful of others depending on the book. Compare that to Carolina, Tampa, Toronto, and Florida sitting at heavy negative prices to make it, and the picture becomes clear.

The most interesting miss candidates in the East from a betting standpoint:

Washington Capitals: Aging core, declining underlying numbers, and a roster that's been living on borrowed time for a couple of seasons now. Their make-the-playoffs price at some books still feels shorter than their actual probability warrants.
New York Islanders: Physical and gritty but limited offensive ceiling. In a tight East race, teams that can't generate offense consistently tend to fall short in the final weeks.
Philadelphia Flyers: Still rebuilding despite moments of competitiveness. Their ability to grind out points is real, but their upside is capped in a way that makes late-season collapses possible.

Want more data-driven sports insights? Head over to the Shurzy Content Lab for rankings, predictions, and advanced analysis from our research team.

Which Western Conference Teams Are Most Likely to Miss?

The West bubble is equally crowded, and the market has done a decent job identifying the riskiest teams.

Anaheim, Nashville, and Vancouver currently sit on the wrong side of the make/miss price at most books, meaning the market expects them to fall short more often than not.

Anaheim Ducks: Exciting young talent and surprising early-season numbers, but sustaining that over a full season on a roster still in development is a genuine ask. Their make price may be shorter than their probability supports.
Nashville Predators: Competitive enough to stay close but lacking the depth and star power to push through a crowded Western bubble. Their aging structure makes a late-season fade more likely than a run.
Vancouver Canucks: Injury history and goaltending inconsistency are the two factors most likely to sink them. When Demko is healthy they're dangerous. When he's not, their odds drop sharply and their results follow.

Which "Safe" Teams Could Shock-Miss the Playoffs?

These are the low-probability, high-headline misses. They're unlikely, but the scenarios exist.

Colorado, Dallas, Vegas, Edmonton, Carolina, and Tampa are all priced as near-certainties to make the field. Their miss probability sits in the low single digits at most books. That's the right pricing — these teams have the roster quality and structure to withstand bad stretches.

The most realistic shock miss from this group, if forced to pick one, is Edmonton. Their floor depends heavily on goaltending holding up, and a goaltending collapse combined with a brutal schedule stretch is the only realistic path to them falling out of the picture. It's unlikely. But it's the scenario worth monitoring if you're looking for a high-upside fade on a team currently priced as a lock.

Check the Live Odds on Shurzy to track real-time lines, futures markets, and betting trends across the NHL, NBA, MLB, UFC and more.

How to Bet Playoff Miss Markets

The practical application is straightforward once you know which teams are vulnerable.

Fade overpriced make tickets: Any team sitting at -200 or shorter to make the playoffs with genuinely fragile underlying numbers is worth fading at plus money on the miss side. The implied probability at -200 is 67%. If you genuinely think their true probability is closer to 55%, that's a real edge.
Parlay connected bubble teams: If Utah misses, Winnipeg likely makes it. If Toronto collapses, Boston benefits. Parlaying correlated outcomes on bubble teams is one of the cleaner ways to use this information.
Monitor injury news closely: Playoff miss bets become significantly more valuable the moment a key player goes down on a bubble team. The market adjusts, but not always fast enough to eliminate the edge before you can get your bet in.

Share this post: