The Next Defensive Star to Go Top 10

Reese's No. 1 Overall Ranking Is Genuinely Rare

Reese's emergence as the consensus No. 1 overall prospect on CBS Sports' top-200 big board represents a genuinely rare achievement.

Defensive players going No. 1 overall is a historical outlier. The position has been dominated by quarterbacks for most of the modern draft era.

Even landing in the top 5 requires a combination of positional demand, physical profile, and tape quality that almost no defensive prospect achieves.

Reese checks every box.

Reese's rare achievement:

• CBS Sports' No. 1 overall prospect
• Defensive players going No. 1 is historical outlier
• QB position dominates modern draft era
• Landing top 5 requires perfect combination

Before rivalry week explodes, check the Content Lab. From Heisman angles to upset alerts, it's all in the Lab.

Physical Tools Plus Football Intelligence

At 6-foot-4, 243 pounds, he combines the coverage athleticism of a safety with the power and gap-fitting ability of a traditional inside linebacker.

Creating a positional archetype that defensive coordinators across the NFL have been trying to build around for a decade.

His football intelligence (the processing speed with which he identifies run-pass option keys, identifies block release patterns, and triggers to the football) is described by multiple scouts as elite-level.

Intelligence projection:

• Processing speed identifying RPO keys
• Identifies block release patterns instantly
• Triggers to football at elite level
• Projects upward to NFL rather than requiring refinement

Think you know Saturdays? Prove it in Gridzy. Build your picks. Beat your buddies.

Historical Comparison to Myles Jack

The historical comparison point is Myles Jack of UCLA, who entered the 2016 draft as the consensus top linebacker before a knee injury dropped him to the second round.

Reese has the physical tools Jack had, plus an injury-free college career and a performance record that Jack's knee never allowed him to fully establish.

A second comparison that scouts are drawing is Patrick Queen of LSU (the 2020 first-round pick who transformed Baltimore's defense) but with considerably more range and size.

Comparisons scouts are drawing:

• Myles Jack's physical tools (without injury)
• Patrick Queen's impact (with more range and size)
• If Ravens had Queen in 6-4 frame, would've built defense around him
• That's the projection NFL teams working with

If you're calling an upset, back it up in Gridzy.

Caleb Downs Presents Second Most Compelling Top-10 Case

Caleb Downs, Ohio State's safety, presents the second most compelling top-10 case.

The context for Downs' projection is critical: safety is the one defensive position that has most consistently gone outside the top 10 in recent drafts.

Not because teams don't value safety but because the quarterback demand at the top of every draft class pushes non-quarterbacks down the board.

Downs entering a class where quarterback quality is described as historically strong (multiple QBs are projected as top-5 picks) means his safety position could push him to 7-12 rather than 1-5.

Downs' realistic projection:

• Safety position consistently goes outside top 10
• QB demand pushes non-QBs down board
• Historically strong QB class in 2026
• Could push Downs to 7-12 range rather than 1-5

Between games? Piggy Arcade's top picks are ready.

Keldric Faulk Most Realistic Edge Rusher Top 10

Keldric Faulk at Auburn is the most realistic edge rusher to crack the top 10.

His 6-foot-6 frame and 12-sack production against SEC competition created the kind of tape that causes NFL general managers to override their scouts' positional value charts and simply take the best player available.

Edge rushers with Faulk's combination of height, length, and pass-rush production have historically gone in the top 10 at a very high rate.

Faulk's top-10 case:

• 6-6 frame rare for edge rushers
• 12 sacks against SEC competition
• GMs override positional value charts for him
• Height, length, production historically go top 10

Rueben Bain Jr. at Miami is the second edge rusher in top-10 discussions.

No late kickoff? No problem. Piggy Arcade's live. Switch from tailgate mode to top slots in seconds.

Jermod McCoy Would Be Most Dramatic Top-10 Story

The defensive player who represents the most dramatic potential top-10 story is Jermod McCoy of Tennessee at cornerback.

USA Today's rankings placed McCoy as the top cornerback in the class, and cornerbacks go in the top 10 far less frequently than edge rushers or linebackers.

McCoy's combination of ball production, press coverage technique, and the credibility of his SEC competition record gives him a profile that every team selecting in the 7-15 range with a secondary need will have at the top of their board.

McCoy's longshot top-10 path:

• USA Today's top CB in class
• CBs go top 10 far less frequently
• Needs team with CB deficiency picking 7-10
• Ball production plus press coverage technique

College football is chaos. The Content Lab makes it simple.

The Bottom Line on Next Defensive Star Top 10

Arvell Reese is next defensive player to go top 10 (CBS Sports' No. 1 overall, 6-4 and 243 pounds, defensive players going No. 1 is historical outlier). Reese has Myles Jack's physical tools without injury, Patrick Queen's impact with more range and size. Caleb Downs presents second most compelling top-10 case (USA Today's No. 1 safety, historically strong QB class could push him 7-12 range). Keldric Faulk most realistic edge rusher top 10 (6-6 frame, 12 sacks against SEC, GMs override positional value charts). Jermod McCoy would be most dramatic top-10 story (USA Today's top CB, position goes top 10 far less frequently).

Think you know Saturdays? Prove it in Gridzy. Build your picks. Beat your buddies.