Best Home Run Derby Moments of All Time

Key Insights

• Ken Griffey Jr. is the face of the Home Run Derby in the same way Jordan is the face of the Dunk Contest, and his 1993 Camden Yards warehouse shot is the event's single most iconic image
• Josh Hamilton's 28-homer first round at Yankee Stadium in 2008 is the most jaw-dropping single round in Derby history, made better by the fact that he didn't even win
• The 2019 Guerrero Jr vs Joc Pederson semifinal is the best round-by-round exchange in Derby history, combining 80 combined home runs with three swing-offs before anyone advanced

Ken Griffey Jr., 1993 and 1998

Griffey is the Home Run Derby the same way Bird is the 3-Point Contest. He didn't just win. He made the event feel like his personal stage while he was on it.

His 1993 appearance at Camden Yards produced the most famous single shot in Derby history. He hit a ball that cleared right field, kept going, and struck the B&O Warehouse beyond the wall, a shot so long that it remains the reference point for "how far can a baseball actually travel" conversations decades later. MLB.com opens its legendary Derby moments list with Griffey specifically because of that shot:

• Three total Derby titles, the first player to win it three times
• The backward cap and effortless upper-deck contact that made his Derby appearances look different from everyone else's
• A 1998 follow-up that reminded everyone the 1993 version wasn't a fluke

Fox's Derby history piece opens with Griffey as the event's defining face, and nothing in the record since has changed that assessment.

Take a break from the action and try Gridzy, our free online grid game that sports fans everywhere are hooked on.

Josh Hamilton, 2008

The most purely jaw-dropping single round in Derby history, delivered by a player who had been through things that made the moment feel like more than just a hitting display.

Hamilton hit 28 home runs in the first round at the old Yankee Stadium. The crowd, which had seen plenty of great Derby performances on that field, treated each successive homer with escalating disbelief. By the time the round ended, the building had essentially given him a standing ovation for a competition he hadn't won yet.

He didn't win. He ran out of gas in subsequent rounds and finished second to Justin Morneau. But the first round is the only thing anyone remembers from that Derby:

• 28 home runs in a single round, a number that felt impossible while it was happening
• Shots that reached sections of the old stadium that hadn't seen balls land there in years
• A crowd reaction that turned an elimination round into a celebration

Bleacher Report called it one of the most jaw-dropping displays in Derby history, and the specific word "jaw-dropping" is accurate in a way that most sports descriptions aren't.

Vlad Guerrero Jr. vs Joc Pederson, 2019

The best head-to-head exchange in Derby history, and a semifinal that was better than most finals have ever been.

Guerrero and Pederson each hit 29 home runs in regulation. They went to overtime. They went to a second overtime. They went to a third swing-off before Vlad finally advanced, combining for nearly 80 home runs in a single semifinal matchup that lasted long enough to feel like its own complete event:

• 29 each in regulation, which would have won most Derby rounds outright in any other year
• Three separate swing-offs before either player advanced
• A combined 80 home runs that made the actual final feel like a cooldown

ClutchPoints' ranking of greatest Derby moments focuses on this specific matchup as the event's best competitive exchange, and the argument is straightforward: two players producing historic numbers simultaneously over an extended period is a better product than one player producing historic numbers alone.

Find your winning edge with Shurzy AI, our predictive model that delivers smart picks and detailed analysis to help you make more informed bets.

Bryce Harper at Home, 2018

The most dramatically structured Derby performance in recent history, delivered in front of a home crowd that needed exactly what Harper gave them.

Harper was trailing Kyle Schwarber in the final with time running out. He got hot in a way that produced the specific energy that timed formats generate when someone is chasing a total:

• Tied Schwarber on his last regulation swing with the Washington crowd completely unhinged
• Won in bonus time to send the home audience into full celebration mode
• Delivered the local hero moment that the Derby in Washington had been set up to produce

MLB.com highlighted the Washington performance specifically as an example of the modern timing format creating cinematic finishes that the old unlimited-outs format couldn't generate. Harper's final round is the best argument for that case.

Why the Modern Format Made It Better

The Home Run Derby's shift to a timed format changed the event's entertainment structure in ways that most fans didn't fully appreciate until they saw what it could produce.

The old format, where players had a set number of outs and the round could drag indefinitely, created some memorable moments but also created dead time that the timed version eliminates completely. The countdown clock at the end of a round, with a player behind on the total, generates the specific pressure that made Harper's Washington finish feel like a playoff moment rather than an exhibition:

• Every swing in the final thirty seconds carries elimination weight regardless of how many came before it
• Bonus time for swings over a threshold adds another layer of cinematic possibility
• The format rewards the players who get hot at the right moment rather than just the ones who hit the most overall

The best Derby moments since the format change have all involved the clock, which is the clearest evidence that the structural shift improved the product.

Level up your knowledge in the Shurzy Content Lab, with 101 guides, terms, strategies, and bonus breakdowns for sports betting and casino games.

Why the Derby Keeps Delivering

The Home Run Derby works because it takes the most universally understood thing in baseball, a ball hit very far, and removes everything else until that single quality is all that's left. No defense, no pitching matchups, no strategy. Just power, and whoever has the most of it in the next four minutes.

Griffey made it feel effortless. Hamilton made it feel impossible. Vlad and Joc made it feel like a legitimate competition where two excellent performances happened to overlap. Harper made it feel like a home crowd's fantasy come true. The event keeps producing versions of all four, which is why it keeps being worth watching.

FAQ

What is the greatest Home Run Derby performance ever?

Ken Griffey Jr.'s combination of the 1993 warehouse shot and his overall Derby legacy makes him the strongest answer for career performance. Josh Hamilton's 2008 first round is the strongest answer for single-round dominance.

Why didn't Hamilton win in 2008 despite hitting 28 in the first round?

Because the Derby rounds are independent, and Hamilton ran out of steam in subsequent rounds after the historic first one. Justin Morneau won the title. Hamilton won the cultural memory of that night.

What made the Guerrero-Pederson 2019 semifinal so special?

Because both players were producing historic numbers simultaneously over an extended period, which is a better product than one player dominating alone. Three swing-offs after 29 home runs each in regulation is a combination that had never happened before and hasn't been replicated since.

Has the timed format made the Derby better?

The evidence from the best moments since its introduction suggests yes. Harper's Washington finish and several other dramatic countdowns have produced entertainment that the old format structurally couldn't generate.

Who has won the most Home Run Derby titles?

Ken Griffey Jr. was the first three-time winner. Pete Alonso won back-to-back titles in 2019 and 2021, making him the most recent multi-time champion and one of the event's modern defining figures.

The Home Run Derby has been baseball's power-hitting myth machine since the 1980s, and the moments it keeps producing suggest it's nowhere near running out of material. Griffey's warehouse shot, Hamilton's 28, Vlad and Joc going to triple overtime. The event takes the simplest thing in sports and keeps finding new ways to make it feel extraordinary.

‍