Sports Betting

MLB Teams Most Likely to Miss the Playoffs 2026

Some teams look safe until they aren't. The gap between a preseason playoff lock and a genuine miss candidate can close in six weeks, and the betting angles on both sides of that gap are some of the most profitable in baseball. Last year's playoff teams carry the most interesting miss probability because the market prices them with familiarity rather than current roster quality. Here's which teams are most likely to fall short of the 2026 postseason and how to bet on it.

March 26, 2026

Which Last Year's Playoff Teams Are Most Likely to Miss?

These are the teams that made the 2025 postseason but carry real regression risk heading into 2026. Fading them on make/miss markets or their win total overs is where the value lives.

Cincinnati Reds are CBS Sports' pick as the most likely of last year's 12 postseason clubs to fall out. They finished at 83 wins, the division isn't weak, and their roster improvements heading into 2026 are modest at best. SI's playoff odds show them at +145 to make the playoffs, which implies roughly a 40% miss probability. That's not a lock — that's a coin flip dressed up in playoff pedigree.

San Diego Padres are arguably the biggest story in the entire miss market. MLB.com gives them just a 21.8% playoff probability, which is nearly a four-in-five chance they miss the postseason entirely. The reasoning is direct and specific:

They lost Dylan Cease, Luis Arraez, and Robert Suarez in the offseason
FanGraphs gives the Dodgers, Giants, and Diamondbacks better NL West playoff odds than San Diego
SI shows them at -155 to make it, which sounds comfortable until you realize that still implies roughly a 40% miss rate

The Padres miss at +350 or better is one of the most interesting bets in baseball right now. The market hasn't fully caught up to how much roster turnover actually cost them.

Which Teams Are Sleeper Miss Candidates?

These teams aren't getting the same attention as the Padres or Reds, but their underlying numbers tell a concerning story.

Houston Astros are the sleeper miss candidate nobody wants to say out loud. Their eight-year postseason streak ended in 2025, the AL West is harder with Seattle, Texas, and Oakland all pressing, and MLB.com gives them just a 34.7% playoff probability. SI has them at -185 to make it, which sounds comfortable until you do the math — that implies roughly a 35% miss rate baked directly into the consensus price.

The tell: Isaac Paredes is already on CBS's trade deadline candidates list as a potential mid-season chip. Teams don't put their third baseman on the trade block in preseason planning if they're confident about their direction.

San Francisco Giants sit at +215 to make the playoffs at SI, meaning the market already thinks they miss more often than not. Their record over the last four seasons: 79 to 81 wins every single year. They failed to add a frontline starter and their bullpen ranks 29th in projected WAR. Logan Webb alone doesn't fix a roster that has been stuck in mediocrity for half a decade.

Minnesota Twins have a win total of just 73.5, Pablo Lopez is out with Tommy John surgery, and Byron Buxton's availability is a perennial question. The Twins sit at +500 to make the playoffs, which makes them a near-certain non-factor rather than a genuine bubble team.

Tampa Bay Rays carry a two-year playoff drought into 2026 with a modest projected WAR ranking of 17th in the league. Their quiet offseason and thin roster construction make them a team to fade in win total and playoff make markets.

Which Teams Are Already Eliminated Before the Season Starts?

These teams aren't miss candidates — they're certainties. The question is how bad it gets.

Colorado Rockies are priced at -400 to finish with the worst record in baseball. In 2025 they went 43-119, were outscored by 424 runs, and finished 50 games out of first place. They're not competing for a playoff spot — they're competing for the best draft pick. The only betting angle here is the total losses over/under and whether their historic futility generates any specific prop value.

Other confirmed non-factors include the White Sox, Nationals, Athletics, and Marlins. Their playoff make prices range from +400 to +1600, and none of them have made roster moves that change the fundamental roster quality issues driving those numbers.

Want more data-driven sports insights? Head over to the Shurzy Content Lab for rankings, predictions, and advanced analysis from our research team.

How to Bet Playoff Miss Markets

The practical framework for turning this information into actual bets.

Target the Padres miss aggressively: At +350 or better, the miss side represents genuine value given how dramatically their roster quality dropped. MLB.com's 21.8% playoff probability implies the miss price should be much shorter than it currently is at many books.
Fade the Reds on win total: Their 83-win floor from 2025 came with a stronger roster than what they're running out in 2026. If their win total is set at 82 or higher, the under is worth backing.
Astros miss as a hedge: If you have any futures exposure on AL West teams like Seattle or Texas, a small Astros miss position creates correlated value. If Houston slides, those teams benefit in the standings.
Don't ignore the Giants: +215 to make the playoffs is essentially even money on a miss. Four consecutive 79 to 81 win seasons with no meaningful roster improvement is a pattern, not a coincidence.
Monitor injury news on bubble teams: The Reds, Padres, and Astros are all teams where one significant injury to a key player changes the make/miss calculation immediately. Getting positioned before news breaks is the single most reliable edge in this market.

Before placing your next wager, take a look at the Live Odds on Shurzy. Compare current lines, futures markets, and betting trends across the NHL, NBA, MLB, UFC and more.