The Most Overhyped NBA Team Every Season (And What It Means for Bettors)

The Anatomy of Hype

The mechanism is purely psychological. When a franchise makes a blockbuster trade or free agent signing, the news cycle creates what behavioral economists call availability bias.

The most recently accessed information (the splashy signing) becomes disproportionately weighted in the brain's probability estimate. Books exploit this by setting the newly hyped team's line attractively, capturing the wave of public money, and adjusting as the season reveals actual performance.

This is how sportsbooks make money:

• Set the line to attract public money on the hyped team
• Sharp money comes in on the opposite side at better value
• The public loses, the sharps win, the book collects vig

Every season, one team becomes the vehicle for this cycle. Identifying that team before the season starts is one of the most profitable edges in NBA betting.

Before tip-off, jump into Gridzy and test your NBA IQ.

This Season's Case Study: The Los Angeles Lakers

No team better embodies the overhype phenomenon in 2025-26 than the Lakers.

The Luka Doncic trade in early 2025, one of the most stunning transactions in NBA history, generated titanic preseason excitement that pushed their championship odds from +2,500 (where they were pre-trade) to +500 to +650 by opening night.

Preseason Reddit threads had the Lakers winning the title before a single regular season game was played:

• LeBron James returning to play alongside a generational point guard
• The narrative practically wrote itself
• The hype machine was in full effect

The reality is the Lakers are a legitimate playoff team, sitting comfortably at the top of the West. But the gap between their +500 opening line and where they should have been priced, accounting for Luka's adjustment period to a new system, the absence of established wing depth, and the front office's quiet approach to the trade deadline, represents exactly how hype inflates lines beyond their justified probability.

Want smarter picks without diving into spreadsheets? Hit the Content Lab for NBA betting angles, trends, and quick reads built for real fans.

Historical Pattern: The Hype Teams and Their Fates

The pattern of most-overhyped team per season is extraordinarily consistent across the last decade.

• 2023-24: Brooklyn Nets (Durant-Kyrie-Harden era) opened at +650 and were eliminated in the first round.
• 2022-23: LA Lakers (LeBron-AD "revenge tour") were priced as top-three contenders after trading for Russell Westbrook, then fired their coach mid-season.
• 2021-22: Philadelphia 76ers (Ben Simmons trade era) were consistent top-three betting favorites. Simmons never played a game and Embiid got injured in the second round.
• 2020-21: Brooklyn Nets (Kyrie-Durant-Harden superteam assembled) finished +225 on some books. Lost in the second round to Milwaukee.
• 2019-20: LA Clippers (Kawhi-PG13 signing) opened as co-favorites with the Lakers. Lost in the second round in heartbreaking fashion.

The through-line is identical every single year: franchise-altering acquisitions in the offseason do not automatically translate to title probability. Chemistry, system fit, opponent preparation, and health are variables that cannot be assessed until games are played, and books consistently price the hype before any of these variables are resolved.

If NBA's off tonight, Piggy Arcade keeps the action rolling.

The Fade Strategy: How to Profit From Hype

The "fade the hype team" strategy is one of the most consistently profitable approaches in NBA futures betting over a sufficiently large sample.

The specific execution:

• Step 1: Identify the team with the largest line movement from pre-acquisition to post-acquisition. This year it was the Lakers (from +2,500 to +500 to +650). Last year it was the Rockets (from +1,800 to +750 to +850). The team whose line moves the most after a blockbuster acquisition is the market's prime hype vehicle.
• Step 2: Calculate the implied probability gap. At +500, the market implies a roughly 16.7% championship probability for the Lakers. Advanced simulation models give them approximately 9 to 11%. That gap, 16.7% implied vs. 10% modeled, is the inefficiency.
• Step 3: Invest in the correctly priced alternative. When the Lakers opened at +500 and the Rockets (with an arguably comparable championship profile) opened at +850, the Rockets were the contrarian buy.
• Step 4: Exit after the market corrects. The most important part of the strategy is not holding hype-team fade positions too long. When the public recognizes the overvaluation, typically after 15-20 games reveal the team's true ceiling, books correct the line and the profitable window closes.

If you're calling upsets in this article, go run it back in Gridzy.

The 2026-27 Setup: Who Gets Hyped Next

The most important application of this framework is forward-looking. Based on current offseason trajectory, the most likely candidates for 2026-27 hype inflation are:

Giannis to the Lakers (if it happens): A Giannis-Luka pairing in Los Angeles would generate more hype than any NBA roster construction since the KD-Steph Warriors. Expect their title odds to open at +300 to +400, approximately 10 percentage points overpriced relative to their actual probability. Fade this line on opening night.

OKC if they win the 2026 title: Back-to-back title odds historically get overvalued dramatically. If the Thunder win in June, their 2026-27 line will open at approximately +200 to +250, a price that represents enormous favorite-position risk for what remains a very young team with health uncertainty.

A rebuilt Celtics team with Tatum: If Tatum returns fully healthy and the Celtics add a major piece around him, the Boston media market and national narrative will generate the largest hype cycle the East has seen in years. Expect books to open them at approximately 15 to 20% implied probability, which historically overestimates young superstar returnees from Achilles injuries.

No games on the slate? Switch lanes and check Piggy Arcade's top picks.

The Bottom Line on Hype Cycles

The market is pricing stories, not probabilities. Every time you see a team's line at a number that requires nearly everything to go right, you are looking at a narrative premium.

Narrative premiums are, by definition, the most reliable long-term fade in the market. When the Lakers opened at +500, that was a narrative premium. When the Clippers opened as co-favorites with Kawhi and PG13, that was a narrative premium. When the Nets opened at +225 with the Big Three, that was a narrative premium.

All of them failed. All of them were overpriced. All of them created value on the correctly priced alternatives. The lesson is simple: fade the hype, back the value, and profit from the cycle every single season.

If you're betting this series, don't guess. The Content Lab has the matchup breakdowns ready.