NHL Betting: The Best Online Sportsbooks in Indiana for Hockey

Indiana was one of the first states to embrace legal sports betting after PASPA fell in 2018. Online betting launched on October 3, 2019, and the Hoosier State now has 11+ licensed sportsbooks competing for your action. Sharp NHL odds, deep player props, constant promos, and serious line shopping opportunities make Indiana a hockey bettor's playground, even without a home team.

Is NHL Betting Legal in Indiana?

Yes. Indiana legalized sports betting on May 8, 2019, when Governor Eric Holcomb signed HB 1015. Online/mobile betting launched on October 3, 2019.

Quick facts:

You must be 21 or older. The Indiana Gaming Commission (IGC) regulates and licenses all retail, online, and mobile sports betting sites. Indiana currently has 11+ licensed online sportsbooks as of November 2025: FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM, bet365, Fanatics, BetRivers, ESPN BET, Hard Rock Bet, Bally Bet, and SBK. Remote registration is allowed, sign up and bet entirely through mobile apps from anywhere in-state. No casino visit required. Indiana permits betting on college sports, including in-state teams like IU, Purdue, Notre Dame, and Butler. Player props on college athletes are allowed (unlike some states).

Read more: Best Sports Betting Bonuses and Promos in Indiana

Legal books protect your funds and offer consumer protections impossible on offshore sites. Stick with licensed operators.

Top Sportsbooks for NHL Betting in Indiana

Indiana's loaded with options. Here's where to bet hockey based on what matters most.

FanDuel Sportsbook

Indiana Partner: Blue Chip Casino (Michigan City)

FanDuel's the national leader and brings that quality to Indiana. Sharp puck line pricing, extensive player props (shots, assists, goals, saves, power play points), responsive live betting, and creative same-game parlays. The interface is intuitive, injury and goalie updates are real-time, and NHL-specific promotions drop frequently.

Welcome offer: Bet $5, Get $150 in bonus bets if your first bet wins.

Best for: All Indiana hockey bettors, FanDuel is the default choice.

DraftKings Sportsbook

Indiana Partner: Ameristar Casino (East Chicago)

DraftKings dominates individual player props, pulling from their daily fantasy sports expertise. Shots on goal, assists, blocked shots, anytime goal scorer markets are deep and creatively priced. The shared wallet between DFS and sportsbook is seamless. Same-game parlays are extensive, and Flash Bets feature allows rapid in-game wagering.

Welcome offer: Bet $5, Get $200 in bonus bets if your bet wins + 3 months of NBA League Pass.

Best for: Prop-focused bettors and DFS players.

Shurzy Tip: DraftKings' Flash Bets are clutch for live betting. Quick one-tap wagers during power plays or momentum shifts, no fumbling through menus while the game's moving.

Caesars Sportsbook

Indiana Partner: Horseshoe Hammond

Caesars consistently posts sharp NHL puck line pricing and runs the industry's best loyalty program, Caesars Rewards lets you earn points toward hotel stays, dining, concerts, and more. The mobile app is polished with daily odds boosts and live streaming of select NHL games. Customer service is available 24/7 via live chat, email, and phone.

Welcome offer: Bet $1, double your winnings on your next 20 bets (code SBO20X).

Best for: Bettors focused on long-term loyalty value and premium rewards.

Shurzy Tip: Caesars Rewards is legit for regular bettors. Stack points, cash them in for Vegas trips, concerts, or comped dinners. Your bookie won't do that.

BetMGM

Indiana Partner: Belterra Casino Resort

BetMGM runs aggressive promotional calendars with NHL-specific boosts on rivalry games, national broadcasts, and playoff action. Dedicated goalie props (saves over/under, shutout odds) and deep team props. The "One Game Parlay" feature is well-designed for hockey SGPs. Great selection of prop bets, sometimes hundreds of options on select NHL games.

Welcome offer: Up to $1,500 in bonus bets if your first bet doesn't win.

Best for: Promotion seekers and parlay enthusiasts.

bet365

Indiana Partner: Tropicana Evansville

bet365 is a global powerhouse with what many consider the best live betting platform in the industry. NHL in-game odds update in real-time with exceptional speed. The platform offers live streaming of select events, early cash-out options, and the deepest futures markets available.

Welcome offer: Bet $5, Get $150 or $1,000 First Bet Safety Net.

Best for: Live-action bettors and futures-focused players.

Fanatics Sportsbook

Indiana Partner: Multiple retail partnerships

Fanatics' FanCash rewards program is among the most generous in the industry, earn cash back on every bet, redeemable for merchandise or betting credits. The platform is modern and mobile-optimized. NHL coverage is comprehensive with strong same-game parlay markets.

Welcome offer: Bet and Get up to $2,000 in FanCash Bet Insurance.

Best for: Bettors who value ongoing rewards and sports merchandise.

Read more: NFL Betting: The Ultimate Guide for the 2025/2026 Football Season

NHL Bet Types in Indiana

Indiana sportsbooks offer the full spectrum of NHL bets. Here's what you can play.

Moneyline Betting

Pick the winner, straight up. Shop for the best moneyline pricing across Indiana's 11 books, prices vary.

Puck Line (-1.5 / +1.5)

Hockey's spread. Favorites must win by 2+ goals (-1.5), underdogs get a 1.5-goal cushion. Pricing varies meaningfully between Indiana books, always shop.

Shurzy Tip: With 11 sportsbooks in Indiana, puck line shopping is mandatory. A -110 at FanDuel might be -105 at Caesars. Over a full season, that's real money. Don't be lazy.

Total Goals (Over/Under)

Usually set between 5.5 and 6.5 goals per game. Alternative totals available on most Indiana books.

Player Props

The fastest-growing NHL market. Anytime goal scorer, shots on goal (2+, 3+, 4+), assists, saves (goalies), power play points, blocked shots, and time on ice (select books). DraftKings and Caesars offer the deepest menus.

Read more: Everything You Need to Know About NBA Prop Betting

Period Betting

Bet specific periods: 1st-period moneyline, 1st-period total, 2nd-period total, 3rd-period moneyline. All major Indiana books offer period markets.

Shurzy Tip: Period betting is underrated for tight games. If you're expecting a defensive slugfest, bet the first-period under instead of the full game. You dodge empty-net chaos and overtime coin flips.

Team & Game Props

Team total goals, both teams to score, overtime (yes/no), winning margin, race to 3 goals. Available across all major Indiana books.

NHL Parlays & Same Game Parlays

Standard and SGP options available across all Indiana books. FanDuel leads on NHL SGPs, with DraftKings close behind.

NHL Futures Betting

Stanley Cup winner, Conference winners, division winners, Hart/Vezina/Calder Trophy odds, team win totals. bet365 and Caesars have the deepest futures markets.

Read more: NHL Betting: The Ultimate Guide for the 2025/2026 Hockey Season

NHL Betting Bonuses & Promos in Indiana

Indiana's competitive market drives aggressive promotions. Here's what to watch for.

• Welcome Bonuses: All 11 sportsbooks offer new customer promotions. Current highlights include FanDuel's Bet $5, Get $150 if your bet wins, DraftKings' Bet $5, Get $200 + NBA League Pass, Caesars' double winnings on next 20 bets, BetMGM's up to $1,500 back if first bet loses, bet365's Bet $5, Get $150 or $1,000 Safety Net, and Fanatics' up to $2,000 in FanCash Bet Insurance.
• Odds Boosts: Regional matchups (Blackhawks, Red Wings, Blue Jackets, Predators) and playoff action frequently feature boosted odds.
• Parlay Profit Boosts: 3+ leg parlays often receive 25-50% payout boosts across multiple books.
• Goal Scorer Insurance: "Bet on any goal scorer; if he doesn't score but logs 3+ shots, get money back." These reduce downside risk.
• Playoff Specials: Stanley Cup Playoffs bring some of the best promotional value of the year.

Shurzy Tip: Check multiple sportsbook promotion tabs daily. Indiana's competitive market means frequent, rotating offers. Track promo expiration dates and stack bonuses strategically. This is a bonus-hunting paradise.

Expert NHL Betting Tips for Indiana Bettors

Here's how to bet smarter on hockey in Indiana.

1. Watch Goalie Announcements Closely: A backup goalie can flip a line 2-3 goals instantly. Check official team sources 30 minutes before puck drop. Indiana books update quickly, but there's often a brief window to capture value.
2. Consider Back-to-Back Situations: Teams playing consecutive nights face fatigue. The team on night two of a back-to-back allows more goals. Factor this into totals and puck lines.
3. Shurzy Tip: Back-to-backs hit differently in hockey. If a team's on the second night and traveling, fade them hard. Books price it in somewhat, but casual bettors sleep on this edge, especially late season.
4. Track Pace & Expected Goals (xG): Raw win/loss records can mislead. Expected Goals (xG) measures shot quality and predicts future performance. Free resources: Natural Stat Trick, Evolving Hockey.
5. Home-Ice Advantage Isn't Massive: NHL home advantage is modest, roughly 3-4% edge in win percentage. Don't overweight home teams, but use it as a tiebreaker when models are close.
6. Look for Underdog Value: NHL's low scoring creates frequent underdog wins. Moneylines and +1.5 puck lines often offer value overlooked by casual bettors.
7. Shop Indiana's Deep Market: With 11 sportsbooks competing, pricing varies meaningfully. A 5-cent difference on a puck line or 10-cent difference on a moneyline compounds into real money over a season. Check at least 3 books before betting.
8. Leverage Regional Team Knowledge: Indiana bettors near Chicago, Detroit, Columbus, or Nashville can leverage local knowledge of these NHL teams to find value before national sharps adjust lines.

How to Start Betting on NHL Games in Indiana

Getting started is simple. Here's the play-by-play.

• Pick a licensed sportsbook: From FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM, bet365, Fanatics, ESPN BET, BetRivers, Hard Rock Bet, Bally Bet, or SBK. Create an account by downloading the app or visiting the website with accurate info (full name, DOB, address, last four of SSN). Must be 21+.
• Remote registration: Means you can open an account from anywhere in Indiana, no casino visit required. Verify identity by uploading your driver's license or passport. Deposit funds via debit cards, credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, or e-wallets.
• Claim promotions: By checking the "Promotions" tab for NHL-specific offers. Navigate to NHL/Hockey to find upcoming games with moneylines, puck lines, totals, and props. Compare odds across at least 3 books before placing bets. Place your first bet, start simple with moneylines, puck lines, or anytime goal scorer. Track results and refine your strategy over time.
• Beginner-friendly bets: Anytime goal scorer (lower variance), puck lines (better payouts), first-period unders (less chaotic).

Safe, Responsible Hockey Betting in Indiana

The Indiana Gaming Commission ensures all 11+ licensed sportsbooks comply with consumer protection laws. Your funds are protected, and identity verification prevents underage gambling.

All Indiana sportsbooks offer deposit limits (daily, weekly, monthly), wager limits, time-out periods (24 hours to 6 months), and self-exclusion options. Use these tools proactively.

Responsible Gambling Resources:

• Indiana Problem Gambling Helpline: 1-800-994-8448
• National Problem Gambling Helpline: 1-800-522-4700
• Gamblers Anonymous: Meetings throughout Indiana

If betting ever feels like a burden, reach out. Indiana's resources are confidential and free.

Never bet money you can't afford to lose. Avoid chasing losses. Track your bets. Stick to a plan. Separate betting funds from your everyday account.

Final Thoughts: Indiana's Best for NHL Betting

Indiana's sports betting market is among the most mature in the Midwest with 11+ licensed online sportsbooks competing for your attention.

FanDuel is the top overall choice, sharp pricing, deep props, best SGPs. DraftKings excels for prop bettors and DFS players. Caesars offers the best loyalty rewards. BetMGM leads on promotions and parlay features. bet365 dominates live betting and market depth. Fanatics has the best rewards program. BetRivers offers NHL live streaming.